What To Watch If You Like Who Is Erin Carter? Your Next Thriller Awaits

Madisyn Pagac I 30 Jul 2025

There's a particular feeling, isn't there, when you finish a show like "Who Is Erin Carter?" You're left wanting more of that high-octane excitement, those unexpected twists, and that sense of a hero doing whatever it takes for their family. That kind of storytelling really sticks with you, and it's almost like you need to find something similar right away.

The series, with its blend of intense action, deep personal secrets, and a central figure fighting against a hidden past, truly captivated many people. It had that special mix of a seemingly normal life getting completely turned upside down, and you just had to keep watching to see what would happen next. The stakes felt incredibly real, and you could feel the pressure on Erin.

So, if you’re sitting there, perhaps wondering what to stream next, feeling that familiar itch for another gripping story that pulls you in from the very start, you’ve come to the right spot. We've put together some great picks that share that same thrilling spirit, the kind of shows that keep you on the edge of your seat, just like Erin Carter did. You know, finding the right show is a bit like picking out a watch from a huge selection, whether it’s a sleek Apple Watch Ultra 2 or a classic Rolex; you want something that truly fits your style and keeps you engaged.

What's So Special About Who Is Erin Carter?
Shows with Strong Female Leads and Hidden Lives
Intense Action and Family Secrets
Thrilling Mysteries and International Intrigue
Frequently Asked Questions About Shows Like Erin Carter

What's So Special About Who Is Erin Carter?

Erin Carter really hit a sweet spot for many people. It mixed a lot of things we love in a story: a person with a secret past, some really intense action scenes, and a family that gets caught up in a dangerous situation. The main character, Erin, is a teacher living a quiet life in Spain, and then suddenly, her old life comes crashing back. She has to use some serious skills to protect her daughter, and that's a big part of what makes the show so compelling.

The show keeps you guessing, too. You're always wondering about her true identity and what she did before. This kind of mystery, where the main person is more than they seem, is a really strong draw. It also has that element of ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances, which can be very relatable in a way. The quick pace and the constant feeling of danger really kept viewers hooked, and it's that kind of feeling we're looking to recreate with these other suggestions.

Shows with Strong Female Leads and Hidden Lives

If you liked Erin Carter because of her strength and her hidden abilities, these shows might just be what you're looking for. They feature women who are more than they appear, often with a secret life or a past that comes back to haunt them. It’s a very satisfying kind of story, really.

Alias

This show is a classic for a reason. Jennifer Garner plays Sydney Bristow, a college student who thinks she’s working for a secret part of the CIA. Turns out, it's a terrorist group. So, she becomes a double agent for the real CIA. It’s full of disguises, international missions, and family drama. Just like Erin Carter, Sydney has to keep her true work a secret from those closest to her, and that creates a lot of tension. The show aired a while ago, but it still holds up, and it’s very much about a woman living a double life.

The action is pretty good, and the plot twists come often. You get to see Sydney go through a lot, trying to balance her dangerous spy life with her personal relationships. It's a bit of a wild ride, and you'll find yourself really rooting for her. Plus, the show has a distinct style that was quite popular at the time.

The Night Agent

This Netflix series became very popular very quickly, and for good reason. It follows a low-level FBI agent who works a night desk, waiting for a call that never seems to come. One night, a call finally does come in, and he gets pulled into a huge conspiracy involving a mole at the highest levels of the US government. It has a fast pace, lots of chases, and a strong sense of danger. It's similar to Erin Carter in its constant feeling of being hunted and the need to uncover a large secret.

While the main character is a man, the female lead, Rose, is also very strong and capable, finding herself in a situation way over her head. They work together, and their bond grows as they face incredible threats. It’s a show that just keeps moving, with twists around every corner, and it's quite a thrilling watch.

Killing Eve

This one is a bit different, but if you like a strong, complex female lead and a cat-and-mouse game, you might enjoy it. It's about an MI6 agent, Eve Polastri, who becomes obsessed with a very skilled assassin, Villanelle. Their relationship is complicated, a mix of admiration and deadly rivalry. It's got a unique tone, blending dark humor with intense moments of suspense. The female characters are very central and very well-developed, and that's a big plus.

The show plays with expectations, and the two main women are both incredibly smart and dangerous in their own ways. It’s less about a hidden past and more about a dangerous present, but the psychological games they play are very gripping. You’ll find yourself thinking about it long after you finish an episode, and that's a good sign.

Intense Action and Family Secrets

A big part of Erin Carter’s appeal was the way her past threatened her family. These next suggestions share that theme, where past actions or hidden identities put loved ones in serious danger. The stakes are always incredibly high, as they should be, for a good thriller.

The Old Man

Jeff Bridges plays a former CIA operative who has been living off the grid for decades. When an assassin tries to take him out, he has to go on the run, and his past catches up to him. It’s a very intense show, with some truly amazing action sequences, especially for a man of his age. The series explores themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the lasting impact of choices made long ago. It’s very much about a hidden past coming back to bite you.

The show also features a strong supporting cast, and the story unfolds in a way that keeps you guessing about who to trust. It’s a bit slower than Erin Carter in some parts, but the tension builds beautifully, and the payoff is worth it. You get a real sense of a person who has lived a lot, and that comes through in the performance.

Taken (TV Series)

Based on the popular movies, this TV series explores the origin story of Bryan Mills, the character Liam Neeson played. It shows how he became the highly skilled operative we know, after a personal tragedy pushes him into a life of espionage. It's full of action, and it often involves Bryan trying to rescue people or stop dangerous plots. The family element is still very much there, even if it's about his journey to becoming the protector. It’s a prequel, so it gives you a different look at the character.

The show has a good pace, and it delivers on the action you'd expect from the "Taken" name. If you like the idea of a character with a particular set of skills using them to help others, often in very dangerous situations, this could be a good fit. It’s a bit more straightforward action than some other shows, but it gets the job done.

The Family Man

This Indian spy thriller, available on Prime Video, is fantastic. It follows Srikant Tiwari, a middle-class man who secretly works as a senior analyst for a special cell of India's intelligence agency. He constantly balances his highly dangerous, secret missions with his seemingly ordinary family life, where his wife and kids often feel he’s just a boring government employee. The humor and the tension mix really well, and it’s very engaging.

It has that great contrast of a normal family life against a backdrop of global threats, much like Erin Carter. The action is well done, and the characters are very relatable. It’s a truly compelling watch, and it gives you a look at espionage from a different cultural perspective. You might find yourself laughing one minute and holding your breath the next, which is quite an experience.

Thrilling Mysteries and International Intrigue

If the global settings and the intricate plots of "Who Is Erin Carter?" were what drew you in, these shows will likely hit the mark. They offer plenty of suspense, secrets, and high-stakes situations that cross borders. It's really quite exciting to see how these stories unfold.

Fauda

This Israeli series is incredibly intense and realistic. It follows a team of undercover Israeli agents who pursue Palestinian militants. It’s known for its raw, gritty action and its focus on the human cost of conflict, showing both sides of the story. The characters are complex, and the situations they find themselves in are truly life-or-death. It’s a very powerful show, and it doesn't pull any punches.

The pacing is relentless, and you'll often feel like you're right there with the characters. If you appreciate shows that don't shy away from difficult themes and offer a very authentic feel, Fauda is definitely worth a look. It's a show that will stay with you, I think, for a good while.

Bodyguard

This British thriller became a huge hit for good reason. It centers on a war veteran who is assigned to protect a high-profile politician he despises. He soon finds himself caught in a web of political intrigue and a potential terrorist plot. The show is incredibly tense, with a few moments that will make you gasp out loud. It’s a very well-crafted story, and the lead performance is outstanding.

It’s similar to Erin Carter in its high stakes and the constant threat looming over the main character. The show is known for its incredible opening sequence, which sets the tone perfectly. If you enjoy shows that keep you guessing and have a strong, central mystery, this is a must-watch. It’s quite the ride, and it keeps you guessing.

The Recruit

This Netflix series stars Noah Centineo as a young CIA lawyer who gets pulled into a dangerous world of international espionage when a former asset threatens to expose agency secrets. It balances action and suspense with a good dose of humor, which makes it a bit lighter than some of the other suggestions, but no less thrilling. The main character is new to the spy game, so you get to experience the dangers through his eyes, which is interesting.

It has that element of an ordinary person getting caught up in extraordinary circumstances, much like Erin Carter. The show features a lot of travel and various international settings, adding to the intrigue. If you're looking for something with a bit more fun but still plenty of spy antics, this could be your next binge. It's a pretty fun watch, honestly.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shows Like Erin Carter

People often ask about shows like "Who Is Erin Carter?" Here are some common questions.

Is "Who Is Erin Carter?" a good show?
Many viewers found "Who Is Erin Carter?" to be a very engaging and exciting show. It was praised for its fast pace, the strong lead performance, and its ability to keep audiences hooked with its twists and turns. If you like action, mystery, and a bit of family drama, it's generally considered a good watch.

What genre is "Who Is Erin Carter?"
"Who Is Erin Carter?" fits mostly into the action-thriller genre. It also has elements of mystery and drama, particularly with the focus on the main character's hidden past and her family life. It’s a blend that keeps things very dynamic, which is quite appealing to many.

What's similar to "Erin Carter" on Prime Video?
If you're looking for something similar to "Erin Carter" on Prime Video, "The Family Man" is an excellent choice, offering a great mix of action, espionage, and family life. "The Old Man" also provides intense action and a hidden past theme, though it’s a bit more serious. You can learn more about The Family Man on our site, and also find other great picks if you like shows with strong female leads.

So, there you have it, a collection of shows that should help fill that void left by "Who Is Erin Carter?" Each one brings something special to the table, whether it’s a powerful lead character, heart-pounding action, or deep family secrets. Just like choosing from a vast array of watches, from Citizen to Tissot, finding your next favorite show is about exploring the many options out there until you find the perfect one that makes you feel like you’re in outer space, with its intricate story and compelling characters.

Spiritus Systems - SHOT Show 2019 - YouTube

Emergency First Responder Training - YouTube

Navy Seal Foundation 3250 by Luminox - YouTube

The Soul Of Success